Welcome to Sammy's Italian
Sammy's Italian, located at 9668 N US-301 in Wildwood, FL, offers a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. Renowned for its outstanding New York-style pizza and warm service, patrons frequently commend the restaurant for its welcoming atmosphere and reasonable prices. The menu features a variety of dishes, including hearty pasta and fresh salads, with special offers like Monday meatball nights garnering positive reviews. Whether hosting a large gathering or enjoying a casual lunch, Sammy's Italian stands out for its attentive staff and inviting service, making it a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts.
Sammy's Italian: Reviews & Ratings
Great place. We go there often, the food is very good and fairly priced. We have had quit a few get togethers in the back room with 10-25 people. The is service is always outstanding. Last week we had 20 people for my mothers "Celebration of Life" get together and Jamie took care of us. She was great as usual, thank you.
We went to lunch at Sammy’s based on a recommendation from a neighbor. The service was a 10. We shared a large pizza. It was plenty to bring home a dinner for another night. I had doubts of broccoli as a topping, but my opinion is changed! It looks like there is plenty of room for large groups. We will return for the same pizza again.
Sammy’s pizza is the best I have had over our 10 years here in FL. We finally found an authentic NY pizza! We really enjoy going there because all the staff is friendly and service is the best! All the dishes are excellent to good. I would like to see more Italian or any decor. It’s pretty boring. Maybe even curtains. The staff are so warm and lovely. Wish the decor had a warm cozy feel too.
We had the Mondays special that goes till evening meatballs with pasta and it comes with soup or salad for 8.99. The food was good, salad excellent. Can't wait to try their pizza and other items.
Had a ladies Valentine lunch with 25 ladies. Our waitress Jamie was wonderful. She took drink orders first, told us about any specials, moved on to meal orders and delivered them quickly and efficiently. She checked on refills for drinks, brought extra bread when asked and we all had a delightful meal. Tabs were delivered in a timely manner too. Very enjoyable luncheon. Oh..and we had a separate dining area. I think we will be adding it as one of our regular spots.
Amanda is the best server! She treats you like family. Food is excellent, highly recommend the meatballs!
We were a party of 4. Three had dinners. I opted for a Sicilian pizza. Everyone enjoyed their dinner. Our server, Jamie was both pleasant and efficient. Overall, very nice experience.
So glad we stopped at Sammy's on a recommendation! I got the spaghetti and meatballs (sauce is amazing!), small Caesar salad and Italian Wedding soup. Not only big portions, but excellent food! He got the side of Fettuccine Alfredo, deep fried raviolis with marinara sauce and 2 for 1 beer for happy hour! We both took a little food home for later! The bread is very good! The service (Amanda) was excellent!!! We'll be back!!!!!
Location
-
9668 N US-301, Wildwood, FL 34785, United States Hotline: +1 352-748-1293
If you find yourself in Wildwood, Florida, a visit to Sammy's Italian is a must. Nestled at 9668 N US-301, this welcoming restaurant has positioned itself as a go-to spot for authentic Italian cuisine that tantalizes the taste buds. Renowned for its outstanding service and warm ambiance, Sammy's Italian is not just a dining destination; it's a gathering place for families, friends, and celebrations.
One of the standout features of Sammy's is, without a doubt, their signature pizza. It's not just any pizza; it's been celebrated by patrons as one of the best slices they've encountered in Florida. In fact, one loyal customer, Valerie Bedford, raves about it being the most authentic New York pizza she’s had in over a decade, highlighting the delicious balance of flavors and crispy crust.
The menu offers more than just pizza, catering to diverse palates with hearty pasta dishes and creative specials. For instance, customers like Alexandra have enjoyed delightful meals like the Monday special featuring meatballs and pasta, paired perfectly with a fresh salad, all at an incredible price. This kind of value is a recurring theme in the reviews, as both Ronald Sartini and Jeanne Lomax emphasize the restaurant’s fair pricing.
Sammy's also shines in terms of service. Receiving abundant praise, Jamie, one of the staff members, has been described as wonderful and attentive, making special occasions such as birthday celebrations and lady lunches a breeze. With accommodations for large groups, it’s a perfect place for both intimate dinners and larger get-togethers. The separate dining area ensures that gatherings are comfortable and enjoyable, reinforcing Sammy's reputation as a reliable local dining choice.
Still, as some customers suggested, a touch of Italian decor could elevate the dining experience further. Despite this, the warm and friendly atmosphere created by the staff leaves a delightful impression, making you feel more like family than a customer.
In summary, Sammy's Italian is not just about satisfying your hunger; it’s about creating memorable experiences filled with laughter, good food, and great company. Whether you’re dropping by for a quick bite or hosting a celebration, you’ll always leave with a craving to return.